First Time at Casa Bonita: A Taste of Adventure and Nostalgia

April 18, 2024

Casa Bonita, the famously eccentric restaurant bought by the creators of South Park, has seen an overwhelming surge in popularity, amassing a staggering waiting list of 600,000 eager guests. This resurgence in interest is a testament to the cultural and entertainment value embedded in this unique dining experience. A few years after signing up on their official website, I was thrilled to receive an email informing me that my turn had finally come to secure a ticket. The anticipation built over the years made the experience all the more special, as the long wait highlighted just how sought-after a visit to Casa Bonita has become, turning a meal there into a coveted event.

Upon arrival, the vibe was unmistakable; it felt like stepping into a kind of Disney World of dining, complete with cliff divers, puppet shows, and even Black Bart’s Cave—an adventure that was just as fun as it sounds. The restaurant's ambiance is undoubtedly its biggest selling point, creating a unique experience that blends dining with entertainment in a way that can only be described as a live-action cartoon come to life. The smell upon entering reminded me of that earthy, fountain smell that I only remember from the E.T. ride at Universal Studios and other Disney World park rides.

For dinner, we both decided to dive into the enchiladas. I wasn't expecting much from the food, given the place's reputation more for its entertainment than its culinary prowess. However, I was pleasantly surprised. I chose the green chile enchiladas and found them really good—flavorful and just spicy enough to keep things interesting without overpowering. My fiancé opted for the "Christmas" style, a mix of red and green chiles, but found the red chiles a bit too spicy for his taste.

The sides—refried beans, rice, and coleslaw—were fresh, though pretty average in taste. But let’s be honest, you don’t go to Casa Bonita for the gourmet dining; you go for the experience and the nostalgia, especially if you’re a fan of South Park. Drinks were an adventure in themselves. I tried the skinny margarita which unfortunately came with orange juice, that I didn't much care for, but it was still okay. The regular margarita was a hit, much better balanced. We initially ordered double shots, which proved too strong for our taste; singles would definitely suffice unless you’re in the mood for a really festive evening.

The highlight of the meal, however, was the sopapillas. Served warm and fluffy, they brought out a generous tub of six. Drizzled with honey, they were a delightful treat that perfectly capped off the meal. As for the entertainment, it was charming in its own quirky way. The cliff divers were impressive, making a splash quite literally, and navigating through Black Bart’s Cave was an unexpected thrill. The puppet shows, though clearly aimed at the younger audience, added to the overall kooky charm of the place. There was a little puppet playing an organ/piano that I was hoping would turn its head and be a character from Team America: World Police, but that unfortunately never happened.

Casa Bonita is a place where you come for the food but stay for the fun. There was a tarot reader that was free, but there were too many other guests to get a spot at the table. There was an old western photo booth for 15 dollars. There was an entire arcade. It’s a mix of kitsch and adventure, a sensory overload in the best possible way. The restaurant offers a unique dining experience where every corner holds a new surprise, making it easy to wander and explore. Our first visit to Casa Bonita was a memorable adventure. It’s a place that demands you take it as it comes, with all its flamboyant flair and faults. I can see why it’s likened to a theme park—where else can you enjoy dinner and a show with such a peculiar twist? If you’re looking for a night out that’s out of the ordinary, Casa Bonita might just be the ticket.

< BACK